Evaluations

At Hawks Athletic Club, we take the evaluation process very seriously as it sets the foundation for a successful hockey year for the entire organization (that means you!). If your child is first starting out playing hockey, don't let the below list intimidate you! It is a comprehensive overview to ensure that every player lands in the best place for them.

Our Evaluation Process

Our goal is to have a process that is fair, reliable, and consistent, ensuring that Hawks players are placed in appropriate tiers based on their skill level.

After careful consideration, we have engaged Sports Evaluations to conduct our evaluations this upcoming season. Here’s why we chose them:

  • Transparency: Committed to full transparency in all sports evaluations.
  • Experience: Over 23 years of experience with millions of players evaluated.
  • Integrity: No relation or prior knowledge of any player being evaluated.
  • Passion: Dedicated to providing every child with a fair and equitable evaluation.
  • Fairness: All evaluators are screened and have no affiliation with the players.
  • Unbiased: Evaluators use a confidential platform, ensuring names are not associated with players during evaluations.

Evaluation Criteria

Skating

  • Forward
  • Backward
  • Tight Turns
  • Balance
  • Starts
  • Speed
  • Quickness
  • Agility
  • Edge Control
  • Crossovers
  • Foot Speed
  • Stops
  • Edge Balance

 

Skills

  • Stick Handling / Dekes
  • Forehand / Backhand
  • Dekes / Protection
  • Creativity
  • Shooting (different types)
  • Quick Release (toe drag)
  • Point Shots (Sliding)
  • Accuracy of Shot
  • Shooting in Stride
  • Passing (Choice & Accuracy)
  • Receiving Pass
  • Saucer Pass / Lateral Pass

Offensive/Defensive Tactics

  • Positional Play
  • Knowledge of Game Rules
  • Angling and Gap Control
  • Hockey Sense / IQ
  • Passing / Playmaking
  • Net Drive
  • Attack Triangle / Zone Entries
  • Delays / Cycling
  • Timing
  • Support Teammates
  • Pinching
  • 1 vs 1 / 2 vs 1 Situations
  • Stick Checking
  • Sharing the Puck
  • Interest in the Game

Intangibles

  • Work Ethic
  • Battle / Compete Level
  • Communication
  • Back-Checking
  • Effort on and off the Ice
  • Unselfish Play / Sacrifice
  • Sharing the Puck
  • Involvement in Play
  • Anticipation

Goalie Evaluation Criteria

Goalie Skating

  • Forward
  • Backward
  • Side to Side Agility
  • Balance
  • Edge Work
  • Controlled Skating
  • Agility
  • Strength of Pushes

Positioning

  • Angles
  • Reading of Play
  • Anticipation of Play
  • Makes saves look easy
  • Rarely out of position
  • Doesn't have to scramble

Compete

  • Fights for puck
  • Recovers well
  • Traces puck well
  • Loose puck compete
  • Battles for position
  • Will to cover the puck

Rebound Control

  • Rebounds to safe areas
  • Focus on puck
  • Tracing of puck
  • Movement while down
  • First save control
  • Movement of puck to safe areas

Save Ability

  • Saves
  • Trapping of Puck
  • Square to Puck
  • Transition from Ice to Stance
  • Net Play

Puck Handling

  • Can make pass to teammate
  • Can stop puck behind net
  • Uses glove hand appropriately on stick

Evaluation Scale

The following evaluation scale will be used to assess player performance, ensuring a fair and comprehensive review of their abilities.

8-9: Elite Player/Exceedingly Above Average

The player executes their role effectively and consistently outperforms counterparts. This player had a dominant effect throughout the game and is fully capable of impacting play at this level.

6-7: Above Average/Exceeds Expectations

Good decisions and plays clearly outnumber poor ones. Factors like inconsistent effort or lapses in discipline may prevent a higher rating. This player can compete effectively at this level, with depth being the only limiting factor.

4-5: Meets Expectations/Average

A balanced performance with both good and poor plays. Classified as average, this performance requires more observation. The player made some mistakes, but they were balanced by good decisions, making them a candidate for this level.

2-3: Below Average/Below Expectations

The player struggles to make plays and often makes questionable decisions. Limited effort, hustle, and performance contribute to a rating below average. The player shows potential but has significant limitations at this level.

1: Learning the Game/Newer Player

The player is new to the game and needs much more practice before meeting the performance of their peers. Significant deficiencies are present, but the player is in the learning phase and developing in all aspects of the game.

Evaluation Schedule

Evaluations will take place on the weekends during the first three weeks of September. Please plan to attend all skates in order for your child to be fairly evaluated. You will only know your player's first skate time in advance and each subsequent time will come after each skate. For example, if your player is placed in group A for the first skate, they won't necessarily be in group A for following skates. After their first skate, you will get an email later in the day letting you know their group and time for the next skate. A preliminary schedule will be provided below for your planning and reference. Please wait to hear from your Category Director (U7, U9, U11, U13 Directors) or from our evaluations company about your player's official ice times.

DayDateArenaTimeSession
SAT2026-09-12Castledowns B8:15 AM - 9:15 AMU9 Skills 1
SAT2026-09-12Castledowns B9:30 AM - 10:30 AMU9 Skills 2
SAT2026-09-12Castledowns B10:45 AM - 11:45 AMU9 Skills 3
SAT2026-09-12Castledowns B12:00 PM - 1:00 PM U9 Skills 4
SUN2026-09-13Castledowns B8:00 AM - 9:00 AMU9 Game 1A
SUN2026-09-13Castledowns B9:15 AM - 10:15 AMU9 Game 1B
SUN2026-09-13Castledowns B10:30 AM - 11:30 AMU9 Game 1C
SAT2026-09-19Castledowns A7:45 AM - 8:45 AMU9 Game 2A
SAT2026-09-19Castledowns A9:00 AM - 10:00 AMU9 Game 2B
SAT2026-09-19Castledowns A10:15 AM - 11:15 AMU9 Game 2C
SUN2026-09-20Castledowns A7:45 AM - 8:45 AMU9 Game 3A
SUN2026-09-20Castledowns A9:00 AM - 10:00 AMU9 Game 3B
SUN2026-09-20Castledowns A10:15 AM - 11:15 AMU9 Game 3C
DayDateArenaTimeSession
SAT2026-09-12Castledowns B1:15 PM - 2:15 PMU11 Skills 1
SAT2026-09-12Castledowns B2:30 PM - 3:30 PMU11 Skills 2
SAT2026-09-12Castledowns B3:45 PM - 4:45 PMU11 Skills 3
SAT2026-09-12Castledowns B5:00 PM - 6:00 PMU11 Goalies
SUN2026-09-13Castledowns B11:45 AM - 12:45 PMU11 Game 1A
SUN2026-09-13Castledowns B1:00 PM - 2:00 PMU11 Game 1B
SUN2026-09-13Castledowns B2:15 PM - 3:15 PMU11 Game 1C
SAT2026-09-19Castledowns A11:30 AM - 12:30 PMU11 Game 2A
SAT2026-09-19Castledowns A12:45 PM - 1:45 PMU11 Game 2B
SAT2026-09-19Castledowns A2:00 PM - 3:00 PMU11 Game 2C
SUN2026-09-20Castledowns A11:30 AM - 12:30 PMU11 Game 3A
SUN2026-09-20Castledowns A12:45 PM - 1:45 PMU11 Game 3B
SUN2026-09-20Castledowns A2:00 PM - 3:00 PMU11 Game 3C
DayDateArenaTimeSession
SAT2026-09-12Castledowns B6:30 PM - 7:30 PMU13 Goalies
FRI2026-09-18Castledowns B5:30 PM - 6:30 PMU13 Skills
FRI2026-09-18Castledowns B6:45 PM - 7:45 PMU13 Skills
FRI2026-09-18Castledowns B8:00 PM - 9:00 PMU13 Skills
SAT2026-09-19Castledowns A3:15 PM - 4:30 PMU13 Game 1A
SAT2026-09-19Castledowns A4:45 PM - 6:00 PMU13 Game 1B
SUN2026-09-20Castledowns A3:15 PM - 4:45 PMU13 Game 2A
MON2026-09-21Castledowns A6:00 PM - 7:30 PMU13 Game 2B
WED2026-09-23Castledowns B6:15 PM - 7:45 PMU13 Game 3A
WED2026-09-23Castledowns B8:00 PM - 9:30 PMU13 Game 3B

Frequently asked questions

What if we miss a weekend of evaluations?